M3 Fullmetal Alchemist live action

There are actually 3 live-action Fullmetal Alchemist movies, but in order to not giving you any spoilers I'll only talk about the first two.

Fullmetal Alchemist (2017) and Fullmetal Alchemist: The Revenge of Scar (2022). Both films attempt to capture the magic of the beloved anime series, but with varying degrees of success.

0
0
Comments 21
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    1. This film stays relatively faithful to the early parts of the anime's storyline.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The action sequences are well-choreographed and visually impressive. 
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The production design captures the essence of the fantastical world with its blend of alchemy and early 20th-century aesthetics.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The biggest criticism lies in rushing the plot. 
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The movie crams a lot of story elements from the beginning of the series, leaving them underdeveloped.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    Character development suffers as a result. 
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    Additionally, some might find the acting a bit stiff, and the CGI effects can be uneven.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The sequel delves deeper into the story, focusing on the character of Scar, a mysterious vigilante with a vendetta against State Alchemists. 
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The fight choreography remains impressive, and the world-building is more fleshed out.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    Unfortunately, the film's budget limitations become more apparent. 
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The special effects aren't as polished, and the overall feel is less grand compared to the first movie.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The plot also deviates significantly from the source material, which might alienate fans of the anime.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    Additionally, some might find the acting uneven.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    If you're a die-hard Fullmetal Alchemist fan, these movies might not live up to the high standards set by the anime. 
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The pacing issues and creative liberties taken with the story can be frustrating.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    However, for newcomers unfamiliar with the source material, these films offer a decent introduction to the world of alchemy, automail, and the Elric brothers' quest.  
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    The action sequences and visuals are still enjoyable, and the core themes of sacrifice and brotherhood remain present.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    If you're curious about the Fullmetal Alchemist universe but haven't seen the anime, these movies might pique your interest.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    However, for a more complete and nuanced experience, diving into the anime series is highly recommended.
  • Profile Image
    Walking Puffin
    Author
    It's a Live-Action adaptation with very mixed results.