Walking Puffin
1. This film stays relatively faithful to the early parts of the anime's storyline.
实际上有 3 部真人版《钢之炼金术师》电影,但为了不剧透,我只会谈论前两部。
《钢之炼金术师》(2017)和《钢之炼金术师2:斯卡的复仇》(2022)。两部电影都试图捕捉这部深受喜爱的动画系列的魅力,但成功程度不一。
1. This film stays relatively faithful to the early parts of the anime's storyline.
The action sequences are well-choreographed and visually impressive.
The production design captures the essence of the fantastical world with its blend of alchemy and early 20th-century aesthetics.
The biggest criticism lies in rushing the plot.
The movie crams a lot of story elements from the beginning of the series, leaving them underdeveloped.
Character development suffers as a result.
Additionally, some might find the acting a bit stiff, and the CGI effects can be uneven.
The sequel delves deeper into the story, focusing on the character of Scar, a mysterious vigilante with a vendetta against State Alchemists.
The fight choreography remains impressive, and the world-building is more fleshed out.
Unfortunately, the film's budget limitations become more apparent.
The special effects aren't as polished, and the overall feel is less grand compared to the first movie.
The plot also deviates significantly from the source material, which might alienate fans of the anime.
Additionally, some might find the acting uneven.
If you're a die-hard Fullmetal Alchemist fan, these movies might not live up to the high standards set by the anime.
The pacing issues and creative liberties taken with the story can be frustrating.
However, for newcomers unfamiliar with the source material, these films offer a decent introduction to the world of alchemy, automail, and the Elric brothers' quest.
The action sequences and visuals are still enjoyable, and the core themes of sacrifice and brotherhood remain present.
If you're curious about the Fullmetal Alchemist universe but haven't seen the anime, these movies might pique your interest.
However, for a more complete and nuanced experience, diving into the anime series is highly recommended.
It's a Live-Action adaptation with very mixed results.